Molecular Medicine Israel

Fatal Disease Drug in Limbo

A panel of experts advised the US Food and Drug Administration that BioMarin Pharmaceutical has not demonstrated efficacy of its new drug for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

An advisory panel to the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) convened Tuesday (November 24) to evaluate the strength of evidence for drisapersen, a drug for the often fatal muscle disease Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Drisapersen, produced by BioMarin Pharmaceutical , has been tested in three placebo-controlled clinical trials, but the panel concluded none had shown clear evidence that the drug was helping. By a vote of 15-2, the panel found that the largest trial, which had measured the distance patients walked in six minutes, didn’t show significant improvement in those receiving drisapersen. And most panelists even voted that two of the studies had actually “weakened” the drisapersen’s case for approval, Xconomyreported. “Efficacy has not been established,” Glen Nuckolls of the National Institutes of Health told The Wall Street Journal.

The panel did leave open the possibility that drisapersen could help some children, but it did not vote on whether members through drisapersen should be approved. “We want to gain input from the panel and will engage in substantive discussions today and discuss strength of evidence,” FDA spokesperson Sandy Walsh wrote in an email to Xconomy. The FDA has already raised concerns about the drug’s safety, noting that it has had adverse effects on the kidneys, skin, and blood vessels. “[E]ven in the context of an invariably disabling and fatal disease such as DMD, the safety profile of drisapersen is concerning,” the agency wrote in a written report, according to The Wall Street Journal.

An approval decision is highly anticipated, as patients and parents are clamoring for access to the new drug. There are currently no FDA-approved treatments for DMD, and many patient advocates have touted drisapersen success stories. Erica Muskopf, who showed up at the FDA building in Silver Spring, Maryland, the day of the panel meeting about drisapersen, told The Wall Street Journal that her son “could barely get off the floor” before taking the medication; now, she said, he can run and jump and “has gone almost two months without a fall.”

“Our children are fighting for their lives and they deserve therapies that can change their quality of life, and the outcome of their disease,” another parent who visited the FDA told Xconomy. “This should be the day that the ending of this tragic story is rewritten please approve this drug.”

Sign up for our Newsletter